Paste your SSL certificate and private key to verify they are a matching pair. Mismatched keys cause SSL handshake errors on your server.
An SSL certificate contains a public key, and it only works with the private key generated alongside it. Install a certificate with the wrong key and the web server refuses to start, or visitors get connection errors. It happens more often than you would expect: after a certificate is reissued, when several requests were generated, or when files are copied between servers and renamed.
The certificate and the private key both contain the same public-key values, for RSA the modulus. If they are identical, the pair belongs together. You can run the same check locally without the key leaving your server: openssl x509 -noout -modulus -in cert.pem | openssl md5 and openssl rsa -noout -modulus -in key.pem | openssl md5 should print the same value.
A private key is the one secret that protects your site's HTTPS. Only paste it into a tool you trust, and for keys that protect live production sites, the OpenSSL commands above are the safest option.